Doritos ad contest paid off in a big way, with the snack maker having several funny ads during the Super Bowl. Bud Light, for the most part, had cute commercials, although I'm putting one ad in my Top Five worst. And shockingly, I didn't see much cleavage in Go Daddy's annual spots with Danica Patrick.
I didn't put the McDonald's commercial in the Top Five, but it should have an honorable mention. The ad has Dwight Howard and LeBron James playing basketball for a McDonald's meal, which at the end is taken by Larry Bird. Déjà vu. The ad is similar to the commercial that Larry Bird and Michael Jordan made for McDonald's nearly 20 years ago.
Here are my Top Five Best Commercials and Top Five Worst Commercials.
Top Five Best Commercials:
1. Doritos' four spots: I can't pick. All the spots were funny. Doritos held a contest so viewers could vote online for spots created by consumers. The top three spots would be shown during the Super Bowl. One had a dog removing its bark collar and putting it on its owner, then barking. The dog then gets the chips. The second has a little boy telling his mom's date to keep the hands off mama and the Doritos. The third takes place during a funeral with a young man lying in the coffin filled with Doritos while he watches the Super Bowl on a tiny TV. The coffin tips over and a friend covers for the young man by yelling, "It's a miracle!" Another ad has two guys working out in a gym when one takes the Doritos out of Tim's locker. The other guy warns his friend to hide the chips because Tim loves Doritos. Dressed in Doritos armor, Tim then knocks out the guys by throwing lethal chips. The ad creators receive $400,000, $600,000 or $1 million depending on how many votes their spot received.
2. The Late Show: Imagine a close-up of David Letterman complaining about it being the worst Super Bowl party. As the camera zooms out, he is sitting next to Oprah, and on Oprah's other side sits Jay Leno. In light of the late night TV drama, this spot is incredibly funny. I'm curious how much CBS paid to get Leno in the spot.
3. Bridgestone Tires: A group of guys are racing in a pickup to save a killer whale. As they reach the end of the pier, the driver slams on the brakes, swerves the truck around, and the whale goes flying back into the ocean. I thought the spot would be for the truck, so realizing it was for the tires was unexpected.
4. Dodge: Quick edits of men vowing what they will do, like holding your lip balm, watching your vampire shows, etc., but he will drive whatever he wants. And what he wants is a Dodge Charger. I thought this was a funny spot focusing on all the things that guys do for their women.
5. Google: I liked Google's search ad because it shows you can have an effective and memorable spot without a lot of production. Viewers watch a series of searches beginning with "How to impress a French girl." Other searches include long distance relationships, jobs in Paris, churches in Paris and how to assemble a crib. It was sweet, effective, and Google is always on the screen.
Top Five Worst Commercials
1. Boost Mobile: Boost Mobile did a take-off of the Super Bowl Shuffle, made popular by the Chicago Bears in 1985. Ad features Mike Ditka and Jim McMahon, who graces the stage in an electric mobility scooter. I don't need to see a fallen NFL star that way.
2. Careerbuilder: In this ad, one fully dressed man trudges through casual Friday, which at his workplace means wearing your underwear. Then casual Friday is expanded to every day. Really, you don't want to see this staff in only their underwear.
3. Dockers: Following the Careerbuilder ad was the Dockers ad that featured a large group of men in shirts and underwear marching across a field singing about wearing no pants. The free pants offer was at the end, and I think, the true message of the ad was lost.
4. Bud Light: Guys planning a party talk in electronic voices like T-Pain, who makes a special appearance at the end. Annoying voices make for an irritating spot.
5. Dove: This spot begins with sperm fertilizing an egg and continues with quick edits of life stages. The end shows Dove's new skin care line for men. As I sat watching the long montage, I kept wondering, "What is this?" The visuals just didn't match the product and didn't fit Dove's branding.